W.E. Davis Insurance Agency is People Serving People

We know we provide a valuable product that helps others in their time of need. But we also know the experience of working with an agent that cares is important too. Our agency would not exist without loyal clients and we will do our best to serve you with honesty and integrity.

WE Davis Location Sign Video Thumbnail

The W.E. Davis Insurance Agency Team

We would like to tell you about W.E. Davis Insurance Agency, and introduce you to the talented people who are committed to always improving our service to you.

placeholder image
John Koetz, CIC, CPCU
President - Agent

As the president of the agency, John oversees all areas of agency operations. He specializes in Commercial insurance, with emphasis on Contractors. He also has expertise in Professional Liability, Workers Compensation and Personal Insurance. With over 42 years’ experience, John has his CIC (Certified Insurance Counselor) and CPCU (Chartered Property Casualty Underwriter) designations.

placeholder image
Nicholas Koetz

Nick is a third generation Koetz to work at W.E. Davis. He is the son of John and Libby and grandson to Ed Koetz. Nick has been a licensed insurance agent since 2012 and has been working in the office since high school. Nick offers expertise in personal as well as commercial insurance. Nick is an agency owner and serves as Secretary. When Nick is not working, he enjoys spending time outdoors playing with his Springer Spaniel and office dog, Lola.

placeholder image
Mark A. Willis

Mark has been W.E. Davis since 2017 and comes to the office with over 20 years of experience in the fields of finance, accounting and banking. Mark is a licensed agent in life, health as well as property / casualty insurance. He markets both Personal and Commercial insurance products and performs office management duties for the agency. Mark is also a principal of the agency serving as the Treasurer. In his free time, Mark enjoys spending time with his family, taking part in outdoor activities and working on various projects at his home.

placeholder image
Bob Walter

Bob’s Insurance career began almost 20 years ago and his background is as diverse as they come. With expertise in both the Commercial and Personal sides of the Insurance industry, Bob has experience with most types of business and has even spent time in Farm and Agriculture Insurance. When Bob is not working, he enjoys spending as much time as he can with his son, Leo. Bob also enjoys a vast array of activities such as cooking, practicing martial arts and is an experienced and avid drummer.

placeholder image
Jenna Lawrie - CISR
Associate Agent - Commercial

Jenna joined the W.E. Davis team in 2012 and has almost 15 years of insurance experience.  Her focus in the agency is commercial lines accounts and she enjoys assisting new and existing clients with their business insurance needs. Jenna has her Property & Casualty Insurance license and completed her CISR designation in 2007. She continues to grow her insurance expertise. When she is not in the office, Jenna enjoys spending time with her three children and husband, Drew.

placeholder image
Shannen Bodell - CISR
Associate Agent - Personal

Shannen started with the agency in 2006 and has almost 20 years of experience in the insurance industry. She services our personal accounts including offering new quotes as well as changes. She also keeps track of claims in the agency. Shannen is a licensed insurance agent, has earned her CISR designation, and is a valued staff member of the agency.

placeholder image
JoAnna Tobin
Associate Agent - Commercial

JoAnna joined the agency in 2013 working in the Personal Lines Department. She came to the agency with over 30 years of experience in the insurance industry, specializing in customer service. She is also a commissioned Notary Public since 2006. She recently received her license in Life insurance and helps the agency in that areas as well. JoAnna is an avid reader, enjoys watching British comedies and mysteries and along with her husband Dennis, enjoys bicycling.

placeholder image
Libby Koetz, CPIA

Libby handles the bookkeeping of the agency and also does research on special programs such as advertising and charitable giving. When not working at the agency, Libby is a makeup artist and a consultant with Mary Kay, Inc. She volunteers at many non-profit associations and enjoys spending time with husband, John and sons, Josh and Nick.

placeholder image
Rita Hilsheimer, CISR
Associate Agent - Personal

Rita has many years of personal line insurance experience. She has worked a number of successful agencies and has come to W.E. Davis to help our clients with their personal insurance needs.

placeholder image
Shelly Willis
Insurance Marketing

Shelly is the newest member of the W.E. Staff and brings years of marketing experience to the agency.

We're hiring!

Would you like to work with us? Visit our career page to see our open positions.

Our Story

Learn how our agency has grown for almost a century.

Early 1900s

John L. Davis supported his family by delivering laundry. His customers knew they could rely upon his dependable service, so when J.L. opened his insurance agency, those customers became his first insureds. In those days, the agency was located downtown on Gay Street.


J.L.’s son, Bill, came back from World War I and entered the agency, which was known as J.L. Davis and Son.


J.L. Jr. left his job at Jeffrey Manufacturing to join his father and brother in the family business. The name was changed to J.L. Davis and Sons. The agency moved to the Grand Theater Building on State Street, across from Capitol Square. When the business grew, Bill and J.L. Jr. divided the accounts. J.L. kept the original name, and Bill Davis moved his office upstairs in the Grand Theater Building.


Bill began the W.E. Davis Company. Both agencies prospered, the J.L. Davis Agency under the leadership of J.L.’s daughter, Ruth Davis Tisdall.


Bill Davis, who wanted to spend more and more time in Florida, took Ed Koetz, the claims adjuster for Ohio Casualty Insurance who serviced the agency, into the business. This gave Bill and his wife, Eydthe, the freedom to travel, and gave Ed the opportunity to purchase the agency gradually. When Bill died, it was decided to retain the company name in his honor.


More space was again required, the building at 147 Thurman Avenue, in the village, was purchased and remodeled.


The unique flavor of the original German residents was preserved in the new offices, since their values were much like those of the agency: honesty, integrity and hard work. Ed Koetz, assisted by his wife, Marilyn, carried on the original “family agency” concept established by J.L. Davis. This concept was further enhanced when John Koetz, Ed and Marilyn’s son, graduated from college and joined the agency.


The agency incorporated under the name, W.E. Davis Insurance Agency, Inc. Like their predecessor, Ed and Marilyn Koetz retired from the agency in 1992 to spend more time traveling together.


The agency outgrew its quarters on Thurman Avenue and moved to its present location in the Brewery District. Once again, the company was able to keep its downtown heritage by moving just six blocks from the old location. John and his wife, Libby, continue to keep the family flavor in the agency. However, W.E. Davis Insurance Agency, Inc. has grown in size and includes many in house service associates and producers of insurance.